← Back to community index
# designreview·Active

@Seve https://tscircuit.com/

mention https://tscircuit.com/MustafaMulla29/rp2040 bldc controller Rather than continuing to patch the current BLDC board, I’m considering a clean new board design. Which features should the new board keep, and which parts of the current design are unnecessary? Like should it on

Started by Mustafa7Sep 25, 202636 messages

Discussion

Last active 2 months ago · plain text
Mustafa7original post
<@757706909351411845> https://tscircuit.com/MustafaMulla29/rp2040-bldc-controller Rather than continuing to patch the current BLDC board, I’m considering a clean new board design. Which features should the new board keep, and which parts of the current design are unnecessary? Like should it only be usb pd etc. The board should be small right compared to the current board?
Seve
i will do a video review now, find industry references
Seve
if you don't have an industry reference you're flying blind!
Seve
the link is useless to me because it doesn't build
Seve
so i can't do a video review
Mustafa7
https://tscircuit.com/MustafaMulla29/rp2040-bldc-controller#files <@757706909351411845> review please(follows TI references etc).What do you think I need to add more or remove etc.
Mustafa7
New one!
Seve
<@1079361271687807026> let me know when the build passes!
Seve
make sure your tscircuit version is up to date, you're missing some features
Seve
get rid of U_ENABLE_AND
Seve
it's doing this in a couple places
Seve
source the motor, make sure EVERY connection has a purpose, you have an encoder and a hall effect sensor that we don't have
Seve
the whole board needs to be 25% as big
Seve
it's huge
Seve
find an open source reference design
Seve
know what EXACT BLDC motor you're targeting so that we have electrical current requirements for everything, and we know that the voltage is acceptable
Mustafa7
https://tscircuit.com/MustafaMulla29/rp2040-bldc-motor-controller#files <@757706909351411845> sorry, I pasted the old link, here is the new one. Am trying to make it even more smaller, will paste the references in short time.
Seve
make sure you look at my previous feedback though, it's not spec'd for a particular motor and that's creating issues
Seve
make sure you've selected a motor i can purchase
Seve
what's the PD negotation voltage?
Seve
there's no usbs ports
Mustafa7
<@757706909351411845> https://anaheimautomation.com/blwr092s-12v-8000.html How about this motor? and also I should add usbc-pd and usb 2.0 for rp2040 programming?
Seve
how common is that? Yes keep USB PD separate
Seve
i'm not sure how common that brushless motor is
Seve
ideally it's so common we can get it on amazon etc.
Mustafa7
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B075DD16LK This?
Mustafa7
<@757706909351411845> can you find one? is this good
Sapphire
<:warning:892823499205406760> Please avoid using excessive mentions, as it creates unnecessary notifications and disrupts others — use mentions only when truly needed to keep the discussion focused and respectful; repeated misuse may lead to moderation action.
Sapphire
<:warning:892823499205406760> Please avoid using excessive mentions, as it creates unnecessary notifications and disrupts others — use mentions only when truly needed to keep the discussion focused and respectful; repeated misuse may lead to moderation action.
Seve
hello
Seve
yes that's fine

Want to add to the conversation?

Reply in Discord so your notes stay connected to the source.
Continue in Discord ↗